To Sell or To Rent? That is the Question

To Sell or To Rent? That is the Question

Johana Williams By Johana Williams · Reviewed by Peter Evering ·Nov 2020 ·5 min read

So you’re looking to move out of your home, onto (hopefully) bigger and better things. You’re probably struggling to figure out what to do with your house: do you sell your real estate and let go, or turn it into a rental property? Well, the short answer is, it depends. You have to consider your financial ability, lifestyle, and the opportunities your property has to offer. There are advantages and disadvantages to each option, it all just depends on your situation. Here are the most important things to consider:

  1. What will be profitable?

The first thing to determine is the profitability of each option. Are you still paying a mortgage, or is your house paid off?

If you still have a mortgage payment, will renting out your home produce monthly profit or put you at a loss? Research the going rates for comparable properties in the area or consult a real estate agent to get an idea of your home’s rental price. Then factor in all of your monthly expenses, including mortgage, insurance, HOA fees, property management, utilities, maintenance, and taxes. Be sure to leave room for vacancies as well, since it’s not a given that the property will be occupied every single month.

What would be your investment return if you sold? Look into how much you can get if you sell your home now, taking into consideration the closing costs, agent fees, and other sale expenses. If you don’t stand to make much, it’s probably worth holding on to your property, especially if it will produce a monthly profit, even if it is low.

If your house is paid off, you should still compare how much you would make renting and selling. With no mortgage, you should not be in a rush to sell your house, since it is a continuous source of income until you sell. However, the state of the housing market plays a large role in how long you should hold on to your property.

  1. How is the local housing market?

In addition to calculating profitability at the current moment, it’s essential to take a gander at the future. Consult one or more professionals to learn about local market trends in your neighborhood, city, and state. These trends are not 100% predictable, but depend on city growth, business development, and the national economy. If it looks like your house is starting to decline in value, it’s not a bad idea to sell early.

  1. Are you ready to let go?

Of course, selling your house means goodbye, forever. Consider if there is any chance you may want or need to return to your house, or if it may prove useful to friends and family, or perhaps future children. Property is a powerful asset in more ways than just financially, so deciding to give up ownership of a home is a big deal. If you don’t feel ready to let go, or you aren’t sure what the future holds, you should probably wait before selling. You can always rent until you feel ready to sell.

  1. Can you handle being a landlord?

On the other hand, renting out a property takes time and effort. It is highly recommended to hire a property management company, as being a landlord is at least a part time job. At Utopia, we handle everything from day to day tasks, rent collection, tenant communication, repairs, and maintenance, to showings, evictions, and marketing. Property managers also maximize your property’s profitability, making them a smart investment 99% of the time. Either way, renting a property is still a responsibility and a part of your life, so you should consider if you are ready to take that on.

  1. Taxes

Tax laws are an important consideration to make that can impact the profitability of a property sale. When you sell a home, you are liable for capital gains taxes that can range up to 20%. However, if you are selling your primary residence, you have the ability to exclude $250,000 of capital gains tax, or $500,000 if you are a married couple. That may be of significant value to you, however you can only claim the home as your primary residence for up to three years after you move out or start renting it out.

Similarly, if you are renting out your home, you are only taxed for net income from the rental. That means you are tax exempt from rental income that is spent on rental expenses. Additionally, you can claim a depreciation expense deduction. If your rental is producing a loss, it is possible to offset some of your income. Consult an accountant to determine your specific tax deduction opportunities.

Get Reno Nevada Property Management
For Reno Nevada Property Management Contact Utopia Management today by calling us at (800) 294-4656 or click here to connect with us online.

Johana Williams

Johana Williams

Regional Manager, Utopia Management

Johana Williams is a Regional Manager at Utopia Management with more than 20 years in property management and operational leadership. She writes about property management, landlord-tenant rules, and the rental market for Utopia Management.

Subscribe to our Weekly Newsletter

Exclusive insights for over 10,000 homeowners, straight to your inbox.

"*" indicates required fields

By filling out and submitting this form, I consent to receive marketing emails and SMS messages from Utopia Property Management.

You may unsubscribe or change your preferences at any time. Your personal information will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

30 Years Experience · 9,000 Properties Managed · 4.9 Star Rating
Client Reviews

Trusted by Thousands of Owners

4.9
★★★★★
★★★★★

2,266 verified reviews

  • K
    Kase Weston
    5 out of 5

    I love how dependable Utopia Property Management is. Maintenance happens promptly, rent collection remains…

  • F
    Finnick Turner
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management made property ownership enjoyable and rewarding. I see stable income, happy…

  • B
    Brantley Hall
    5 out of 5

    I feel stress-free with Utopia Property Management. Daily operations, tenant concerns, and maintenance…

  • C
    Cullen Briggs
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management ensures every detail gets attention. I maintained high-quality units, kept tenants…

  • E
    Ellis Henry
    5 out of 5

    I gained real peace of mind with Utopia Property Management. Emergency repairs, regular inspections, and…

  • R
    Rhodes Walker
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management keeps everything running perfectly. I resolved tenant issues quickly, coordinated…

  • S
    Shepherd Miles
    5 out of 5

    I enjoy working with Utopia Property Management. Rent collection runs reliably, repairs occur promptly, and…

  • J
    Judson Hale
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management turned property management into a smooth experience. I handled tasks efficiently,…

  • H
    Holt Anderson
    5 out of 5

    I feel confident in my investments thanks to Utopia Property Management. Inspections, preventive maintenance,…

  • L
    Lawson Barrett
    5 out of 5

    Tenant relations became positive and easy with Utopia Property Management. I addressed concerns quickly, kept…

  • F
    Flynn Rivers
    5 out of 5

    I trust Utopia Property Management completely. Leasing, maintenance, and rent collection occur seamlessly,…

  • Z
    Zayne Marshall
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management improved tenant happiness noticeably. I responded to requests easily, repairs…

  • T
    Tate Emerson
    5 out of 5

    I love how organized Utopia Property Management keeps everything. Financial statements arrive on time,…

  • R
    Ryker Boone
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management exceeded my expectations. I handled leasing effortlessly, units stayed occupied,…

  • R
    Rylan Hayes
    5 out of 5

    I feel fully supported with Utopia Property Management. Maintenance happens promptly, tenants communicate…

  • R
    River Brooks
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management made ownership enjoyable. I experienced seamless rent collection, quick…

  • L
    Ledger Scott
    5 out of 5

    Attention to detail defines Utopia Property Management. Inspections, maintenance, and reporting are all…

  • B
    Briggs Hunter
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management delivers outstanding care for every property. Communication stays prompt, issues…

  • B
    Bowen Briggs
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management enhances property value and tenant experience simultaneously. Well-maintained…

  • G
    Griffin Hayes
    5 out of 5

    Clear reporting and transparency make Utopia Property Management stand out. Monthly statements are easy to…

  • L
    Lennox Carter
    5 out of 5

    Working with Utopia Property Management feels collaborative. Recommendations are thoughtful, and property…

  • A
    Archer Boone
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management’s proactive approach prevents small problems from turning into major issues.…

  • Z
    Zander Walsh
    5 out of 5

    Trustworthy service is the hallmark of Utopia Property Management. Every promise is kept, creating confidence…

  • C
    Callum Hines
    5 out of 5

    Utopia Property Management reduces vacancy periods with effective marketing and strategic tenant placement.…

  • R
    Ronan Foster
    5 out of 5

    Professionalism shines in every interaction with Utopia Property Management. Their team handles challenges…

Let us help you. Your property, professionally managed.

Get Started